States Take Lead on AI Health Care Rules as Federal Oversight Lags

Where you live may soon determine how much artificial intelligence (AI) influences your health insurance coverage. With little federal regulation in place, states are stepping in to shape the rules governing AI’s role in health care.

On April 15, Lauren Sausser, a correspondent for KFF Health News, joined WAMU’s Health Hub to discuss the growing divide between federal and state approaches to AI regulation in health care. While supporters highlight AI’s potential to improve speed, efficiency, and lower costs, critics—including physicians—warn of risks such as insurance denials without human oversight.

States Take the Lead as Federal AI Rules Lag

Federal oversight of AI in health care remains sparse, leaving states to craft their own policies. This gap has created a stark contrast in the Washington, D.C., metropolitan area, where Maryland and Virginia have adopted opposing strategies for regulating AI in health insurance.

Maryland’s Cautious Approach

Maryland has taken a more restrictive stance, prioritizing patient safety and transparency. The state’s regulations aim to ensure that AI tools used in health insurance decisions are subject to human review, reducing the risk of automated denials without proper oversight.

Virginia’s Pro-Innovation Stance

In contrast, Virginia has embraced a more permissive approach, encouraging the adoption of AI to streamline health care processes. The state’s policies favor innovation, allowing insurers to leverage AI for efficiency gains, even if it means less direct human involvement in decision-making.

These divergent approaches highlight the broader debate over AI’s role in health care: Does it enhance care and reduce costs, or does it introduce risks that outweigh its benefits?

Why the Divide Matters for Patients

The differences in state-level AI regulations can have real-world consequences for patients. Residents in Maryland may benefit from stronger protections against automated insurance denials, while those in Virginia could experience faster, AI-driven approvals—but with less transparency or recourse in disputes.

As states continue to navigate this uncharted territory, the lack of federal guidance leaves patients and providers in a patchwork system where the rules—and the risks—vary by location.

KFF Health News: A Leader in Health Policy Journalism

KFF Health News is a national newsroom dedicated to in-depth reporting on health issues. It operates as one of the core programs under KFF, an independent organization focused on health policy research, polling, and journalism.