2026 NFL Draft Grades: 4 Teams Earn Low Marks, But One Could Surprise

The 2026 NFL Draft produced a mix of surprises, missed opportunities, and potential hidden gems. While no team outright failed by making selections, four franchises earned the lowest grades due to questionable evaluations, misplaced priorities, or overlooked needs. However, one team stands out as a potential outlier—capable of defying expectations and turning their draft class into an 'A'.

Why These 4 Teams Earned the Lowest Grades

Grading an NFL draft class isn’t just about reaching for players or failing to address needs. It’s about evaluating the board effectively when making a pick. These four teams struggled in that regard, leaving room for doubt about their long-term impact.

• Denver Broncos: Limited by the Jaylen Waddle trade, the Broncos failed to secure significant value at any critical need position. Their best selection was a mid-round running back with modest upside.
• Jacksonville Jaguars: The Jaguars deviated so drastically from the consensus that it appeared they were evaluating an entirely different draft class. Their second-round pick—a blocking tight end with limited receiving ability—raised eyebrows across the league.
• Los Angeles Rams: The Ty Simpson selection at No. 14 was seen as a risky, unconventional choice. Beyond Simpson, the Rams failed to address key roster upgrades, leaving major questions about their draft strategy.
• Minnesota Vikings: The Vikings’ first-round pick, Caleb Banks—a defensive tackle from the University of Florida—raised concerns due to his injury history, including chronic foot problems. Additionally, the team neglected to prioritize the secondary, a glaring need.

The Vikings: A Sleeper Success Story?

While the Rams’ Ty Simpson could emerge as the franchise quarterback, the Minnesota Vikings present the most intriguing case for a draft class turnaround. Operating without a full-time general manager, head coach Kevin O’Connell and defensive coordinator Brian Flores shouldered the draft’s heavy lifting.

Flores, known for his defensive acumen and player development, reportedly identified Banks as a high-potential talent. Despite Banks’ injury concerns, his athleticism, length, and explosiveness in short bursts suggest untapped potential. With proper conditioning and development, his issues may prove correctable.

The Vikings’ draft process, marked by improvisation under pressure, could ultimately yield an unexpected payoff. If Banks and other late-round selections pan out, Minnesota might look back at 2026 as a turning point for the franchise.

"Many of Banks’ issues are correctable. The foot injury history is worrisome, but he’s violent, athletic, and long—in short bursts."

Getting Banks into a tailored NFL conditioning program could unlock his abilities, proving Flores’ eye for defensive talent was spot-on. The Vikings’ draft class, though initially panned, may yet defy expectations.