For professional athletes—especially those who rely on their arms—throwing out the first pitch at a baseball game is a high-risk, low-reward scenario. Miami Dolphins quarterback Malik Willis discovered this firsthand last night before the Phillies-Marlins game in Miami.

If Willis had climbed the mound and delivered an effortless, semi-fastball down the middle—reminiscent of former President George W. Bush’s post-9/11 ceremonial pitch—no one would have batted an eye. For NFL quarterbacks, the first pitch only becomes noteworthy when it goes wrong.

In Willis’ case, it did.

He stepped up with confidence: windup, leg kick, everything looked polished. Then the ball sailed high and wide, far from the strike zone. This wasn’t a rapper’s ceremonial toss; it was a $50 million (over two years) starting NFL quarterback—an athlete whose job is throwing accurate passes.

While the moment generated minor buzz on a slow Saturday, it changes little about Willis’ standing. The Dolphins’ aggressive pursuit of the quarterback—orchestrated by new general manager Jon-Eric Sullivan and new coach Jeff Hafley—signals their belief in his ability to perform at a high level.

Yet the incident underscores a recurring truth: professional athletes stepping outside their sport to throw a first pitch rarely gain anything from the experience.