Steven Pinker and Mona Charen Debate Enlightenment Values in a Pessimistic World

Steven Pinker and Mona Charen Examine Global Progress and Enlightenment Values

In a recent episode of The Mona Charen Show, cognitive psychologist and bestselling author Steven Pinker joined commentator Mona Charen to dissect why the world is advancing in ways often overlooked—and why pessimism persists despite measurable improvements.

The discussion centered on the enduring relevance of Enlightenment values, including reason, science, and liberal democracy, while addressing the growing resistance to these principles from both progressive and populist movements.

Why Do People Believe the World Is Worse Than It Is?

Pinker and Charen explored the psychological and media-driven factors fueling widespread pessimism. Despite decades of declining poverty, violence, and disease, many still perceive global conditions as deteriorating. The conversation highlighted how cognitive biases and news cycles amplify negative perceptions, obscuring long-term progress.

The Backlash Against Enlightenment Ideals

The podcast examined two major sources of opposition to Enlightenment values:

• Progressive skepticism: Criticism of science, reason, and liberal institutions from the left, often rooted in postmodern critiques.
• Populist nationalism: The MAGA movement’s rejection of globalism, expertise, and democratic norms in favor of tribalism and authoritarian tendencies.

Charen and Pinker argued that both strains of backlash threaten the stability of democratic societies and the pursuit of evidence-based policymaking.

Media’s Role in Distorting Perceptions

The hosts discussed how news media prioritizes conflict and crisis over incremental progress, reinforcing a narrative of decline. Pinker cited data showing that while bad news spreads faster, good news—such as reductions in war, famine, and disease—often goes unreported.

"The world is getting better, but our brains are wired to notice the worst things happening right now. That’s why we feel like everything is falling apart, even when it isn’t." — Steven Pinker

About The Mona Charen Show

The Mona Charen Show is a weekly podcast featuring in-depth, one-on-one conversations on political and cultural issues. New episodes are released every Monday and are available on all major podcast platforms, YouTube, and the show’s website.

For ad-free editions of the show, listeners can subscribe to Bulwark+, the premium membership tier of The Bulwark.